Market Decisions versus Political Decisions - Island of Sanity

Island of Sanity


Market Decisions versus Political Decisions

An example

Here is the fundamental difference between decisions in a free market, and decisions in a political forum.

Let's consider a simple example: Suppose many people are deciding what to have for lunch. Let's say that 51% of them want hamburgers, 25% want chicken, 15% want tacos, and 9% want pate de foie gras. (I'm just making these numbers up for an example. These aren't based on any real survey.)

If this decision is made in a free market, 51% of the people will go to hamburger places, 25% to chicken places, etc. Each individual will get the lunch that he wants. Restaurants that serve the kind of food people want will do well. Restaurants that serve food that few people want will do poorly or go out of business.

Of course, it's not quite that simple. People may not be able to find a restaurant serving what they want. Etc. But that's the principle.

If this decision is made politically, at best we will take a vote. As a majority want hamburgers, hamburgers will win. Then everyone will have to have hamburgers. For the majority who wanted hamburgers, this is fine. For the minorities who wanted other things, they will be out of luck. They will be required to have hamburgers whether they like it or not.

This is the advantage of a free market. In politics, the majority get what they want and minorities are out of luck. In a free market, everyone can get what they want.


I suppose at this point someone might object that the government wouldn't necessarily force everyone to abide by the will of the majority. The law might allow people choices. But my point is that once it becomes a political question, that is exactly what will happen. The government does not pass laws that say, "Everybody do whatever you want. Do whatever you would have done if there had been no law." What would be the point of passing such a law? Once the government gets involved, it takes away choices. A law that does not tell people that they must do this or they must not do that is not a law. It might be a suggestion, but it is not a law.

Another possible objection is that I am creating a ridiculous example. Why would the government pass laws about something as trivial and harmless as what you have for lunch? My first response is that I am just using this as an example; I am not saying that this is a law actually being debated in Congress or anything like that. My second response is that it isn't all that far out an example anyway. It is not significantly different from many existing laws. We have laws regulating how much companies must pay their employees, how much a loaf of bread must weigh, and how much water your toilet can use. Indeed lunch is not an off-the-wall example. New York City recently passed a law banning foods with trans-fats.

The not-so-best cases

I said that "at best" we will take a vote. In real life, politically powerful groups, like rich corporations and activist groups, will work to influence the laws. Suppose some health group comes along and says that hamburgers are bad for you and people should eat chicken instead. A small minority that is very outspoken can have a lot of influence. Of course the chicken and taco restaurants will back this group, not because they will benefit from hamburgers being restricted or banned, oh no, but because they are concerned about public health. Politics is rarely really about the will of the majority. More often it is about the will of the rich and the loud.

Furthermore, in practice you rarely get to vote on each specific issue. Rather, you vote for a candidate who takes positions on many issues. The chances that you will agree with everything he says are small. You vote for the candidate who agrees with you the most, and have no choice but to accept some number of issues where you disagree. Then you hope that he actually lives up to his campaign promises. Often he doesn't.

© 2009 by Jay Johansen


Sasquatch May 23, 2014

"A small minority that is very outspoken can have a lot of influence."

Like Ancel Keys. His deliberately flawed report to congress is what started the whole "food pyramid" thing and got the FDA involved in manipulating our diet. That led to the skyrocketing obesity and diabetes rates everyone has been complaining about lately. Never underestimate the power of one evil man to corrupt an entire society.

Jay Johansen May 23, 2014

Evil and/or simply mistaken. I don't doubt that many very harmful laws are passed by people who truly, honestly believed that they were doing good.

Londok Jul 23, 2014

I could watch Schrndlei's List and still be happy after reading this.

oakland raiders jerseys Sep 22, 2017

I must point out my love for your kind-heartedness supporting people who require guidance on this important subject. Your real commitment to passing the message all-around ended up being particularly productive and have made somebody just like me to achieve their dreams. Your entire important facts means a great deal a person like me and somewhat more to my office workers. Thank you; from each one of us.

ray ban sunglasses Sep 29, 2017

I precisely had to thank you very much all over again. I do not know the things that I could possibly have accomplished without the ideas documented by you relating to this topic. It was actually a real distressing condition for me, nevertheless noticing the well-written fashion you treated it made me to jump over joy. I'm just thankful for this guidance as well as hope you are aware of a great job you happen to be providing instructing some other people all through your web site. More than likely you have never come across all of us.

coach outlet store online Sep 30, 2017

I must show appreciation to the writer just for bailing me out of such a problem. Just after exploring throughout the world-wide-web and finding techniques that were not productive, I believed my entire life was over. Being alive minus the approaches to the issues you've solved by way of your write-up is a serious case, and those which might have adversely damaged my entire career if I hadn't discovered your web blog. Your main skills and kindness in dealing with every item was priceless. I don't know what I would have done if I had not come upon such a stuff like this. I am able to at this time relish my future. Thanks a lot very much for your reliable and result oriented help. I won't hesitate to suggest your site to any individual who desires support on this topic.

yeezy boost 350 v2 Sep 30, 2017

My wife and i have been so joyous John could do his studies through the precious recommendations he gained through your weblog. It is now and again perplexing to just choose to be offering procedures which usually other people could have been trying to sell. So we consider we've got the website owner to appreciate for this. The illustrations you made, the simple blog navigation, the friendships you will help to foster - it's most excellent, and it's assisting our son in addition to our family believe that that matter is awesome, which is certainly wonderfully pressing. Many thanks for everything!

nike huarache Oct 1, 2017

I enjoy you because of each of your work on this web page. My daughter really likes managing research and it's obvious why. I learn all concerning the dynamic medium you render very important information on the blog and therefore inspire participation from website visitors on that issue while our favorite simple princess is now understanding a whole lot. Take pleasure in the remaining portion of the new year. You're carrying out a tremendous job.

nike shoes Oct 2, 2017

Thanks a lot for providing individuals with a very memorable possiblity to check tips from here. It's always very useful and also full of amusement for me personally and my office mates to visit the blog at the very least 3 times every week to find out the fresh things you have. Not to mention, I'm just usually contented for the stunning principles served by you. Certain two tips in this posting are in reality the simplest we have all ever had.

nike free run Oct 2, 2017

My husband and i got very satisfied when Jordan could finish up his investigations because of the ideas he acquired from your weblog. It is now and again perplexing just to happen to be handing out tricks that some other people could have been trying to sell. And we also consider we have got the website owner to thank for this. Those explanations you've made, the easy web site menu, the friendships you will make it possible to create - it's got all astounding, and it is making our son in addition to the family consider that that matter is awesome, and that is truly essential. Thank you for all the pieces!

replica rolex Oct 3, 2017

My wife and i were really contented John could carry out his research via the precious recommendations he grabbed out of your web pages. It's not at all simplistic to just always be giving away guides which other folks could have been making money from. And we all already know we've got you to thank because of that. Most of the illustrations you made, the straightforward web site navigation, the friendships you will assist to promote - it's mostly overwhelming, and it is letting our son and us understand the idea is excellent, which is certainly really serious. Thank you for everything!

atlanta falcons jerseys Oct 4, 2017

I would like to get across my affection for your kind-heartedness in support of those people that must have help with this one subject matter. Your real commitment to passing the solution around ended up being certainly valuable and have empowered workers just like me to achieve their desired goals. This warm and friendly information denotes much to me and a whole lot more to my fellow workers. Warm regards; from all of us.

nike store Oct 5, 2017

I want to express appreciation to this writer just for rescuing me from this type of incident. Right after researching throughout the online world and finding advice that were not beneficial, I assumed my entire life was well over. Living without the approaches to the issues you've fixed by means of the short post is a serious case, as well as those which might have in a wrong way damaged my entire career if I hadn't come across the blog. That ability and kindness in playing with a lot of stuff was precious. I am not sure what I would have done if I had not discovered such a thing like this. I am able to at this moment look ahead to my future. Thanks a lot so much for your impressive and result oriented guide. I will not be reluctant to recommend your web page to anybody who should have guidance on this situation.

Add Comment