Generation Ships - Island of Sanity

Island of Sanity



Technology (General)

Generation Ships


In science fiction, ships often travel to other star systems in days, or even hours. They use a "warp drive" or "hyperspace" and travel many times faster than light. In real life, the best science we have today says that faster than light travel is impossible. Even if it was theoretically possible, we are nowhere close. The fastest a human being has ever travelled is Apollo 10, which reached 24,791 mph. The fastest a man-made object has ever travelled is NASA's Parker Solar Probe, which reached 430,000 mph. That sounds awesome. But it's 0.064% of the speed of light.

There are fundamental limits to how fast a rocket can travel. To go faster, you need to burn more fuel. But then you need more fuel to carry the fuel. And more fuel to carry that fuel. It's exponential. I haven't personally done the calculation, but I've read that accelerating even a small spaceship to the speed of light would require more fuel than there is matter in the galaxy.

So okay, maybe you don't use any sort of rocket. Maybe you use solar sails or a Bussard Ramjet. Still, reaching anything near lightspeed is far beyond our present technology.

But let's suppose, for the sake of discussion, that we could build a ship that reaches 1% of the speed of light. At that speed, it would still take over 400 years to reach the nearest star (Proxima Centauri). Clearly, no one is going to live long enough to complete the trip.

This has led to the idea of a "generation ship". We build a ship that we know will take hundreds or even thousands of years to reach its destination. The initial crew accept that they are committing not just their entire lives to this trip, but also the entire lives of their children and grandchildren, possibly many generations. Their children will never see either Earth or the destination. They will be born on the ship, live their entire lives on the ship, and die on the ship.

I've read some articles that say that the technology to build such a ship exists today. It would be hugely expensive, but possible.

But sadly, no. There are many problems with a generation ship. Some of these are technical problems that may be solved with future technology. Others are more fundamental.

First, all resources on board would have to be recycled 100%. Water, air, etc. 99.9% isn't good enough. They'd run out centuries before they reached their destination.

If fuel is a problem, the engines are only going to fire twice: once at the start of the trip to get them going, and then again at the end of the trip to bring them to a stop. Most of the trip is coasting. There is little friction in space so they don't have to burn fuel just to keep moving. But that means they have to burn fueld at the end to stop. But that's a problem. Enginges that haven't been used for hundreds of years will have to still work properly. Maybe they could do test firings along the way, but that would burn some of their limited fuel.

They'd need radiation shielding. On Earth, the atmosphere and the magnetic field protect us from radiation. A space ship wouldn't have anywhere near enough atmosphere to provide significant shielding. Maybe they could use lead or water, but that's more weight to push. Perhaps they could create an artificial magnetic field. But then you're talking technologies far in advance of anything we have today.

Earth is big enough to be resilient. If a plant disease wipes out a crop, it can be painful, but it doesn't destroy humanity. A generation ship wouold be much, much smaller, and therefore more fragile. A plant disease could not only wipe out a crop, but wipe out all future crops.

But the biggest problems involve people.

Maybe you could find volunteers willing to commit their lives to a mission even though they know they will never see it completed. But their children and grandchildren and possibly many more generations will also have to be committed to this mission. And no one asked them. They would be born committed to a job they never agreed to. Maybe some one would be excited about the mission and partifcipate enthusiastically. Others might be resigned, this is their fate. But some number would rebel. They might turn the ship around and head back to Earth. If they've gone too far for that to be possible, they might zone out. They might refuse to work, spending their lives playing videeo games or doing drugs or forming violent gangs.

What would the politics on such a ship be like? No one could appeal to Earth in a conflict. If Earth had a ship sitting ready to go, it couldn't go much faster than the generation ship. It could take centuries to catch it. If a disagreement came to violent conflict, the generation ship could destroy itself.

The skills you neef for the voyage are totally different from the skills you need when (or if) you arrive at the destination. For the voyage, you need people skilled in maintaining electronics and mechanics, growing hydroponic crops, etc. At the destination, you need people who know how to build farms and cities, grow crops in open air, adapt to local conditions, etc. Even if you included people with such skills in the original crew and told them to train future generations, how well would this training work when it won't have any practical application for hundreds of years? Again, some may enthusiastically learn it and pass on their knowledge. But others will conclude this is pointless and stupid, they will never use these skills in their lives. How many young people today rebel against learning algebra? Imagine trying to teach them a skill where you tell them, You will never use this material in your life. You are learning it so you can teach it to others who will teach it to others, etc, and hundreds of years from now it will be useful.

© 2026 by Jay Johansen


Comments

No comments yet.

Add Comment

Name
E-mail
Comment