Bill Nye Takes a Stand Against Creationism ... and Against Logic - Island of Sanity

Island of Sanity


Bill Nye Takes a Stand Against Creationism ... and Against Logic

Bill Nye, famous for the children's TV program "Bill Nye the Science Guy", recently made a statement criticizing creationists. I never saw his TV show. I hope his science was better than his logic. Because his statement had two main points, and both were logically incoherent.

1. What to tell your children

I say to the grownups, "If you want to deny evolution and live in your world that's completely inconsistent with everything we've observed in the universe that's fine. But don't make your kids do it."

-- Bill Ney

Now let's think about this carefully for a moment. Someone either agrees with Mr Nye that creation theory is false, or they disagree and think it's true. (Or they might be undecided or seek some middle ground, but let's skip over those possibilities as they don't affect the logic here.) If they think creation theory is false, then they are not likely tell their children that it is true. Mr Nye's admonition is irrelevant. But of course Mr Nye isn't talking to people who think creation theory is false here: He's talking to people who think it's true. But if they think it's true, then why should they not teach it to their children? Mr Nye gives no reason. He just says they should. Why would someone tell his children something that he believes to be a lie just because Mr Nye says so? Lie for Nye?. Why?

2. How to be a winner

Denial of evolution is unique to the United States. I mean, we’re the world’s most advanced technological — I mean, you could say Japan — but generally, the United States is where most of the innovations still happens. People still move to the United States. And that’s largely because of the intellectual capital we have, the general understanding of science. When you have a portion of the population that doesn’t believe in that, it holds everybody back, really.

-- Bill Ney

So let's try to follow the reasoning here: Point 1: The United States is the world leader in science and techology. Few other countries come close -- the only serious competitr that Mr Nye can think of is Japan. Point 2: The United States is the only country in the world where creation theory is strong.

And so Mr Nye comes to the obvious conclusion: if the United States wants to continue to excel, it should adopt the ideas of people who have consistently done less well. Umm ... what? If the U.S. is the world leader in science and technology, then doesn't it make more sense to say that other countries should imitate the U.S.? If you see that sports team A always wins and sports team B always loses, which team do you want to copy?

If the U.S. had only recently adopted creation theory, then you could theorize that the U.S. was still limping along on its past "intellectual capital". But creation theory has bene widely accepted in the U.S. since the country has existed. For as long as America has been a scientific leader, creationism has been strong. Interestingly enough, countries that were scientific leaders in the past, like Britain and Germany, were leaders when they were mostly creationist. It has only been since they "converted" to evolution that these countries lost their technological edge.

© 2012 by Jay Johansen


Filipe Jul 23, 2014


Juliana Oct 3, 2015

It should be noted by all fair miendd scholars and commentators that the Bible itself nowhere claims the earth to be only 6000 years old. That is an assumptioned assigned to it by sometimes overzealous but misguided Christians. Additionally, there are several notable scholars who maintain that there is a gap in the middle of verse one in Genesis Chapter 1 which implies that what is thought to be the creation of the earth is a really a recreation of the earth.The Bible is not a science book. It merely contains information that mankind cannot discover on their own.

Add Comment